The details change every year. This year it’s a “new chip card.” Last year it was free COVID test kits, a genetic testing kit, or a Medicaid recertification fee. Next year it’ll be something else, maybe an offer for free or discounted prescription drugs, or a “special” enrollment deadline. But underneath the changing script, the same handful of warning signs show up again and again, whether the contact comes by phone call, text, email, or a mailer that looks like it’s from a government agency.
Learning five categories of scams by name is a losing game, since scammers simply invent a new one. Learning to recognize the pattern works regardless of what this year’s version is called.
It doesn’t matter whether a scam arrives as a robocall, a text message, an email, or a glossy mailer sitting in your mailbox next to your real Medicare paperwork. According to the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services Office of Inspector General, fraud schemes targeting Medicare beneficiaries are constantly repackaged around whatever is in the news, from diabetic supplies and prescription drugs to genetic testing and Medicaid “unwinding.” The packaging changes. The underlying tactics don’t.
That’s why it’s more useful to know the five signs below than to memorize this year’s specific scam headline.
According to the Social Security Administration (SSA), Medicare representatives, Social Security, and the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services (CMS) don’t cold call, text, or email you to start a conversation about your benefits, your card, or your premium. If you weren’t expecting the call and didn’t request a callback, that alone is reason to be skeptical, no matter how official the caller ID, return address, or email signature looks.
Scammers rely on panic to stop people from thinking clearly. A message claiming your Medicare coverage will be canceled, suspended, or terminated unless you act immediately, verify information, or pay something right now is a classic pressure tactic. According to the National Council on Aging, if you qualify for Medicare, they won’t take away your eligibility for reasons like not signing up for a specific plan, and real coverage changes don’t work that way.
No-cost, unbiased service
Compare all major plans and carriers
Local, licensed insurance agents with 25+ years of combined experienceMedicare is not issuing new physical cards that require you to verify your information or pay a fee. If a call, text, or mailer says your card is being replaced and asks you to confirm your Medicare card or Social Security number, or a payment to receive it, that’s the scam, not the card.
The SSA notes that legitimate Medicare costs don’t get collected by credit card number, bank account information, gift card, wire transfer, or cryptocurrency read out over the phone. Neither does Medicare ask you to read back a one-time verification code that was just texted to you; that’s a sign someone is trying to take over an account, not confirm one. If the requested form of payment feels unusual, it’s a red flag no matter what story comes with it.
A text or email with a link to click, a QR code to scan, or a phone number to call back can look completely legitimate, right down to matching fonts and logos. The tell isn’t how convincing it looks. It’s whether the message steers you toward contact information it provides, instead of one you looked up independently.
Agent tip:
“Treat any unsolicited message about a new or replacement Medicare card as fake by default. Medicare communicates about your actual account through the mail and through your secure Medicare.gov account, not by asking you to verify your Medicare card or Social Security number over the phone.”
You don’t need to identify the scam category to protect yourself. If a call, text, email, or mailer sets off any of the five signs above:
If it’s real, Medicare or your plan will still be there when you call back on your own terms. If it’s a scam, you’ve lost nothing by checking first.
Whatever this year’s scam is called, it will probably lean on one of these five signs: unexpected contact, a benefit threat, a new-card request, an unusual payment method, or a supplied link and callback number. You don’t have to keep up with every new scam name to stay safe. Just stop, hold onto your information, and contact Medicare directly through Medicare.gov or 1-800-MEDICARE before you respond to anything.
Not sure if a call, text, or mailer you received is legitimate? Call (623) 223-8884 to talk with a local, licensed Connie Health agent. We can help guide you to the right next steps.
No-cost, unbiased serviceCompare all major plans and carriers Local, licensed insurance agents with 25+ years of combined experience
No. Medicare representatives, Social Security, and CMS don’t initiate contact by phone call, text, or email to discuss your benefits, your card, or your premium. If you didn’t request the contact, treat it with suspicion.
No. Any call, text, or mailer claiming you need to verify your Medicare card or Social Security number, or pay a fee for a new Medicare card, is a scam, not a real card replacement process.
Caller ID and return addresses can be faked or spoofed. Looking official isn’t proof of anything. What matters is whether the contact was unexpected and whether it’s pressuring you to act immediately.
Call 1-800-MEDICARE (1-800-633-4227) right away to report it and ask about getting a new Medicare number. You can also contact the Senior Medicare Patrol for help documenting the incident.
Report it to 1-800-MEDICARE (1-800-633-4227), the Senior Medicare Patrol, or the Federal Trade Commission at ReportFraud.ftc.gov. You can also report it directly to your Medicare health or drug plan.
Read more by Renee van Staveren
Since 2009, I've been writing about complicated, technical issues, with the goal of making topics like Medicare and healthcare easier to understand. I've been writing about Medicare since 2021 and healthcare since 2019. I am an AmeriCorps alumni. I enjoy gardening, reading, and DIYing.
Call Now
